Skip to main content

Due to decreasing use over the years, I have decided to disable the forum functionality of the site.

Forums will still be available to view but new posts are no longer allowed.

Solid PH producing a spotted foal

Hi gang ! It's a long time I didn't come over here ... and I had to create a new account. I have a question for you ... How can a solid red dun PH mare, bred to a black andalusian, produce a spotted foal ? I was soooooo sur that it was impossible .... Thank you all for your answers :)

Third Peppermint Sun, 07/11/2010 - 11:18

Pictures of both the mom and dad would be helpful, too.

The foal looks frame to me? Frame can hide in solid looking horses. My best bet is the Paint Horse dam is actually frame positive, which would make sense as long as she didn't test negative.

Jenks Sun, 07/11/2010 - 11:52

NICE foal! And yep. Frame! Can be frame and be solid (OK - socks make her not solid!) too! I would guess she might also be splash with that face!

Gosh look at the shoulder he put on that foal.... I can see mom's a little and it sure doesn't look like hers...is it your stallion?

zoom Sun, 07/11/2010 - 11:59

I think the dam has no white on the face.
I asked for pictures. I'll load them as soon as I have some.

I have a foal of the same sire ... and he has the same shoulders ! :)

accphotography Sun, 07/11/2010 - 13:12

Either proof that frame can cause funky face white on it's own or that splash can exist in a totally solid horse. Either could easily be true, but in this case I think that face is frame.

Yes, "solid" pintos CAN produce foals with markings. Especially those hiding frame. This is one of the reasons we encourage everyone to TEST all breeding stock for frame. If she'd been bred to a stallion carrying frame because it wasn't known the dam was as well that could have been very sad. :sad

Songcatcher Sun, 07/11/2010 - 13:35

I totally agree with those above. Both Frame and Splash (and even Tobiano, although not in the case of your foal) can be so minimal as to be considered Solid and then throw a wildly marked foal. The Black and White stallion in my avatar is from two parents both registered as Solid (but obviously not).

rabbitsfizz Mon, 07/12/2010 - 09:48

The mare has socks, ergo, she is not "solid", she is merely designated so by a blinkered society!
I would vote for Frame and Splash, Splash alone[i] could[/i] cause the funky face markings, but it normally does so when it has something else to "work" with, so Frame + Splash for me.
If your mare is /has Sabino, she is not "solid" either!!! :booty

zoom Tue, 07/13/2010 - 07:32

So, a solid paint horse is a horse with no white at all (no socks, no white on the face) ?

If it is, what about another breed with socks and white marking ?
What is the difference ?

Songcatcher Tue, 07/13/2010 - 07:38

[quote="zoom"]So, a solid paint horse is a horse with no white at all (no socks, no white on the face) ?

If it is, what about another breed with socks and white marking ?
What is the difference ?[/quote]
No difference. ANY White is the produced of SOME Pinto (White producing) gene. Some may cause EITHER minimal or maximum markings. Some may only cause minimal markings.

zoom Tue, 07/13/2010 - 08:41

I'm not sure to clearly understand ... probably because I try to manage with english ;) Sorry if I look to be slow to understand ... I just want to clearly understand everything ;)

Are we talking about white markings on face and legs or pinto horses ?

What I understand is that any horse that have white on the face and legs, even if he's not a pinto or paint horse, may produce a pinto ....

rabbitsfizz Tue, 07/13/2010 - 09:38

Yes, Zoom, we are indeed!
We now believe that all and any white markings, including "normal" white markings, on any horse, any breed, are caused by one of the Pinto patterns.
This is how Welsh, Arab and TB to name but three traditionally non-Pinto breeds, have "suddenly" sprouted Pinto animals.
Up till recently the Splashed and Sabino and (in TB ) Frames were either knocked on the head or sold without papers.
Nowadays the patterns are, by some studs, being actively encouraged to express, and they are.
This is what has happened here.