Skip to main content

Due to decreasing use over the years, I have decided to disable the forum functionality of the site.

Forums will still be available to view but new posts are no longer allowed.

What colour will this foal be?

[img]http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y216/slaneyrose/tanzfoal.jpg[/img] Hi all. This foal belongs to a friend who asked me to ask all of you what colour her foal is. The dam is grulla and the sire is black. She thinks it might be a dun because of the dorsal stripe but I think thats just the counter shading and this filly is black? She does have brown on her muzzle but some blacks do as babies dont they? Thanks a lot for your time. :toast

Monsterpony Wed, 07/08/2009 - 20:22

If sire and dam are truly the colors you listed, then she can't be bay-based (no one to give the dominant agouti gene) so no bay dun. I would say black based on the foal coat.

slaneyrose Thu, 07/09/2009 - 17:31

Sorry bout getting the sire colour wrong Tanz! :sad Delighted that I`m not the only one that thinks black or seal (I voted on the irish mini forum lol) :flower :toast

rabbitsfizz Fri, 07/10/2009 - 11:25

She is a true Dun, no Cream, + Sooty.
I know her well, I put her in foal to one of my stallions, the first year she bred.
Dun + Sooty, not Buckskin.

NZ Appaloosas Sat, 07/11/2009 - 00:14

To many people "dun", used by itself (i.e., not in connection with red dun) stands for bay + dun factor. To many, the three basic "dun" shades are: red dun (chestnut + dun), "dun" (bay + dun) and grullo/a (black + dun).

I personally hate the use of just "dun" for bay dun, since I think dun = dun factor, so should be put with its base colour.

Diane

slaneyrose Sat, 07/11/2009 - 12:04

NZ...Are you saying that the people who call her a "dun" mean bay dun? I have seen this mare in the flesh and thought she was a grulla, ie: black dun, is she not then?

rabbitsfizz Sat, 07/11/2009 - 15:27

She is a Dun in that she is not a Dunskin, nor a Buckskin, nor a Black Dun.
She is a Bay base Dun.

OK???

And what has happened to the Forum set up, honestly I leave you people alone for a day...........

slaneyrose Sun, 07/12/2009 - 10:46

[quote]I personally hate the use of just "dun" for bay dun, since I think dun = dun factor, so should be put with its base colour.[/quote]

I agree totally and am really surprised to hear just "dun" means bay dun...especially when so many insist on calling silver dapple...silver black, to be descriptionally correct! :hammer :shock:

rabbitsfizz Sun, 07/12/2009 - 11:26

Silver Black is the correct term, but Silver on it's own is often used as a "base" description, ie "the horse obviously has Silver"
The mare obviously has Dun, the base is obviously Bay, sometimes we do not (or should not) have to spell things out.
But you are right, I was tired and not thinking straight.
I should have spelled it out :laugh1

Jordie0587 Wed, 07/15/2009 - 13:59

I've always heard "dun" in referene to a bay dun.

Claybank or red dun, dun or yellow dun, and grulla.

I've never really used "bay dun" because in my experience it's redundant.

Just goes to show the difference in different areas. I can argue all day long about dun vs buckskin with my friends dad. He insists that "dun" is red dun, and bay dun (or buckskin) are buckskin. I keep telling him that's not really right, regardless of what terms you use because then your grouping buckskins and duns together and they aren't the same, but he doesn't get it. Every time I point out that dun's ALWAYS have a line, he finds a buckskin that has countershading. Drives me bonkers.